How to build credibility comes down to one habit most people skip: do exactly what you said you’d do, every time. Show up as the real you instead of hiding behind a watch or a car, and stay in touch in ways that prove you were actually thinking about the other person. Steve Sims, founder of the luxury concierge Bluefish, calls that credibility “the greatest ROI you would ever get anywhere.”
Steve’s job is making the impossible happen for some of the wealthiest people on the planet. His official bio lists work for royalty, presidents and A-list celebrities, and talks at Harvard twice and at the Pentagon. He’s also the guy who once threw a private dinner at the feet of Michelangelo’s David with Andrea Bocelli singing to the table.
What struck me first, though, was how down-to-earth he is. He talks with nothing to hide. And he made it pretty clear he isn’t in it for the money.
Why showing off kills credibility
Steve has watched a lot of people get rich, and he says you can almost map the stages. First the Rolex. Then a BMW, which becomes a Mercedes, then a Porsche, then a Ferrari, then a Bentley. “They’re constantly striving for validation.” Eventually, once they’ve got more watches than there are minutes in a day, that validation turns into a question of value.
I pushed back on him a little. A multi-millionaire friend of mine told me he started landing more deals with higher-end clients the moment he got a Lamborghini. Same people, same pitch, different car.
Steve didn’t argue. He’s lived it. At one stage he’d turn up to a meeting on a motorbike and nobody took him seriously, then turn up in a Bentley and suddenly he was important. “It was a shame.” He called the fancy car a shield, and he pushed it away. Now he rides an old 1946 Harley to meet billionaire clients in jeans, a T-shirt and sunglasses. “If I turned up in a Bentley or a Porsche, I’d probably look like a fake.”
He even has a name for the status game at a networking event: wristwatch chess. One guy pulls his sleeve back to flash his Patek or his Rolex, and the other guy does it back, or doesn’t, depending on his watch. Steve often goes without a watch on purpose. “It kind of stumps them because you’re not playing the game.”
That’s the difference between borrowed status and credibility. Status is what you wear. Credibility is what people say about you when you’re not in the room.
Credibility rule one: let them meet the real you
I asked Steve for the fundamentals. I said I wouldn’t call it a secret sauce. His answer: “Everyone looks for the secret sauce until you realize there is no sauce.”
His first point: he’s never been frightened to approach anybody or scared to ask a question. When someone meets him, they meet him, not a $5,000 suit, a $20,000 watch or a $150,000 car that’s on lease. “If they like that, great. We’ve already covered a lot of ground. If they don’t, hey, fair enough.” It’s like dating. You’re not going to fall in love with every person you meet.
He added a warning that I think saves people a lot of pain. Don’t try to get the whole room to fall in love with you. Some people will love you, some will hate you, and the ones in the middle are open to a decision. “You can get a majority vote, and that’s all you need.”
He’s proof that it works. When Harvard invited him to speak on not conforming, the event had a dress code. He asked how he could conform to a dress code while talking about non-conforming, turned up in jeans and a T-shirt, and was written up by Women’s Wear Daily as the highlight. They invited him back.
Credibility rule two: keep your word, keep your word, keep your word
This is the one Steve can’t emphasize enough. “Do what you say you’re gonna do.” Sadly, most people don’t. You get “I was gonna do what you want, but I found this” or “I tried this and it came out better.” Steve’s view is simple. Give the person exactly what they asked for. “If you can get that credibility behind you, that is bankable.”
So the two keys are authenticity and following through. Most people only manage one.
When I asked for his last 30-second speech to the world, he said, “Keep your word, keep your word, keep your word.” Then he joked he’d sit down for the other 27 seconds and relax. Simple and straight to the point.
How credibility opens doors money can’t
Here’s what that looks like in practice. A client wanted dinner somewhere exclusive in Italy. Steve took over the Accademia in Florence and set a table for six at the feet of David. Then he wanted to see how far he could take it.
He called Andrea Bocelli’s management and asked if Bocelli would sing for his client. They laughed at him and hung up. But Steve had done work for people at the Vatican earlier that year. He called them and asked if anyone there had worked with Bocelli. They made one call, and Steve got a call back asking whether he wanted Bocelli at 9:00 or 9:30.
“You don’t know all the people, you don’t know all the answers.” But if you’ve got 10 people around you telling others, “pay attention to this person, because if he says he’s gonna do it, it’s gonna get done,” the doors open. That’s credibility compounding.
He sees the same pattern with Elon Musk. Once you’ve built credibility across Tesla, PayPal and SpaceX, people believe you when you say you’ll turn your hand to something new.
Get in the room where you’re the dumbest person
Steve’s favorite people to listen to are Peter Diamandis and Elon Musk, because they take gargantuan projects and simplify them in a couple of lines. They refuse to follow the company line. In Steve’s telling, Elon realized that trimming a rocket’s diameter so it could travel by truck instead of by ship would save a fortune. “This guy just refuses to see any parameters.”
His advice is to get into rooms with that kind of brain power. “You will be the dumbest person in the room, if you’re lucky.” You stand the most to gain. You’d just be like a sponge, absorbing everything. Most of us are focusing on the minor things while they focus on the majors.
Stay in touch like a human, not a mailing list
This is the part I loved most, because it’s old school, back to the basics, and it still works. Steve’s point is that we’ve all got phones that do everything, and the thing we use them for least is actually calling someone. Emails get spell-checked and stuffed with big words. Clients want to know you’re real.
So when he travels, he asks the hotel lobby for 50 envelopes. On the plane he flips through the in-flight magazines, rips out the weirdest product he can find, and writes a quick note on it. One client had just bought a $30 million house in Jupiter, Florida, so Steve sent him a torn-out page of a dolphin-shaped letterbox: “Thought you may need this for your jumbo mansion on the beach now.”
Think about getting that. A handwritten envelope from a hotel in New York, Miami or the Maldives, a bit spongy because a real person folded it. “I guarantee you, you’re gonna open it.” A note like that is one of the few physical touchpoints people still look forward to.
He’s got a version for events too. Do your clients know you’re at a mastermind working on being a better version of you? Send a note: “I’m at this event to improve who I am, but while I was here, I thought of you.”
At the Hotel de Russie in Rome, his room had a card with the hotel’s Dolce Vita cocktail recipe on the back. He asked reception for 200. The manager started to say no, so Steve asked if they’d like their hotel in the hands of 200 of the wealthiest clients in the world. He got the cards. Then he wrote on each one in Sharpie: “Joel, this was a really great drink. Recipe’s on the back. Enjoy it and think of me. Steve.” No typed letter. Just the card in an envelope.
Use a 15-second video instead of an email
Steve’s other trick is quicker still. Instead of emailing “please advise of your best mailing address,” record a 15-second video on your phone from somewhere with a bit of atmosphere, a restaurant, a park, a lake behind you. “Hey Joel, I wanted to send something to you, so what’s your best mailing address?” Text it.
They’ll text back the address. More than that, they’ve heard your tone of voice. “Recording a video is actually faster than sending an email.” It’s more creative, it has more impact, and it takes less time.
And don’t tell me you’re too busy. Steve’s answer to that is blunt. You’re telling me there aren’t five minutes in the day, on a call you don’t want to be on, waiting in a line or sitting on a plane, to write 10 envelopes? “If you don’t wanna improve, hey, don’t do this. But just write the damn letter.” No excuses.
How to build credibility: a weekly checklist
- Write down every promise you made this week and close each one exactly as promised.
- Drop one status prop and let people meet the real you.
- Stop trying to win the whole room. Win the people in the middle.
- Put yourself in one room where you’re the least experienced person there.
- Send three handwritten notes from wherever you are.
- Swap one email for a 15-second video.
- When a gatekeeper says no, ask someone who already trusts you to make the call.
Knowing this won’t build your credibility. Keeping your next promise will.
FAQ
How do you build credibility?
Do exactly what you say you’ll do, every time, and let people meet the real you rather than a status image. Bluefish founder Steve Sims says that kept word becomes “bankable” credibility and earns referrals that open doors money can’t.
Why is credibility important in business?
Credibility turns other people into your advocates. When people vouch that you get things done, introductions and opportunities follow. Steve Sims got Andrea Bocelli for a client dinner through one call from a contact who trusted him.
Does showing off wealth help you close deals?
Sometimes, in the short term. But Steve Sims calls flashy cars and watches a shield and says turning up in a Bentley would now make him look like a fake. Lasting credibility comes from results and kept promises.
How do you build credibility with wealthy or successful clients?
Deliver exactly what they asked for, skip the status games and stay in touch personally. Sims sends handwritten notes on hotel envelopes and short phone videos instead of formal emails, so clients know a real person is thinking of them.
How can you stay in touch with clients without being annoying?
Make it personal and useful. Send a quick handwritten note tied to something in their life, or a 15-second video asking for their mailing address so you can send them something, instead of another generic email.

